Navigant Research Blog

As EV Sales Continue to Disappoint, Makers Eye Car Shares

Scott Shepard — September 25, 2012

EV makers who have tried to develop a model for the mass market have not done well to date, as they must convince buyers that the high initial costs of EV ownership will be offset by the lower ownership cost of more efficient vehicles.  While the argument is mostly true, it takes a long time for an EV to pay itself off (see table below).  In a robust global economy with lots of young progressive buyers aged 18-35, it might be easier to convince potential customers.  Unfortunately, EVs have emerged in an economy that is bumbling at best, and vehicle ownership among those aged 18-35 is falling drastically.

Est.  Total Cost of Ownership Comparison at Current Fuel Prices with 120,000 Lifetime Miles, United States: 2012

Vehicle Class Electricity Price Average Vehicle Price Estimated TCO
BEV-100 Midsize (with tax credit) Low 35,230 34,995
HEV Gas <2.0L Small   21,973 35,422
4-Cyl, 1-2L Gas Compact   17,184 35,588
BEV-100 Midsize (with tax credit) High 35,230 36,423
CNG Compact   26,155 37,398
PHEV-10 Midsize (with tax credit) Low 32,000 40,086
PHEV-10 Midsize (with tax credit) High 32,000 40,821
PHEV-40 Compact (with tax credit) Low 39,145 41,730
HEV Gas 2.4L Midsize   26,783 41,736
4-Cyl Midsize Diesel   23,973 41,867
4-Cyl Midsize Biodiesel   23,973 42,527
4-Cyl, 2.4L Gas Misize   22,421 42,876
PHEV-40 Compact (with tax credit) High 39,145 42,982
SSV 4-Cyl 2.4L Midsize Gas   28,613 47,499
6-Cyl Gas Midsize   26,881 51,882
4-Cyl 2.4L FFV Midsize   25,263 53,440
6-Cyl FFV   29,670 62,169

(Source: Pike Research)

The struggles of EVs aimed at the masses has pushed back deployment in favor of other new plug-in EV models, as plug-in hybrid sales represented by the Volt and Prius Plug-in have shown strength.  The best example of this phenomenon is Ford, which has de-emphasized its Focus Electric in favor of its C-MAX Energi Plug-in Hybrid.

Despite all of this, bright spots are emerging through innovative business models.  One early success has been selling the vehicle and leasing the battery.  Another is simply selling the service the vehicle provides (not the vehicle itself) through car shares.  While the former is certainly an interesting financial concept, its practice is confined to select European markets.  The latter, however, is seeing worldwide adoption.

Car share programs like ZipCar and Hertz Connect have been early adopters of hybrid and efficient vehicles as the fuel savings have cut costs significantly.  A more interesting development has been the increased number of vehicle makers eyeing car shares as launching points for their EVs.  The first major automaker to try this was Daimler, through its subsidiary Car2Go, which has put 300 pure electric Smart ForTwos in San Diego and 300 in Amsterdam.  Other automaker programs utilizing EVs include Renault’s Twizy Way in France, BMW’s DriveNow in San Francisco, and Kandi Technologies’ future EV car share in Hangzhou, China.

The strategy behind this movement has a strong business case as it 1) mitigates the high initial costs of EVs by distributing the EV premium throughout a community of members, 2) allows progressive young motorists the chance to experience the benefits EV ownership without the costs, and 3) harnesses the growing trend of car ownership avoidance among those young, progressive, would be buyers.

The EV movement may be flagging due to a lack of individual interest at current costs, but that doesn’t mean EVs won’t be on the streets.  The major existing car share programs like Car2Go are gobbling up prime service territories.  Automakers on the sidelines are falling behind in a market that could prove as profitable as the Prius is for Toyota.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Blog Articles

Most Recent

By Date


Clean Transportation, Digital Utility Strategies, Electric Vehicles, Energy Technologies, Finance & Investing, Policy & Regulation, Renewable Energy, Smart Energy Program, Transportation Efficiencies, Utility Transformations

By Author

{"userID":"","pageName":"As EV Sales Continue to Disappoint, Makers Eye Car Shares","path":"\/blog\/as-ev-sales-continue-to-disappoint-makers-eye-car-shares","date":"5\/22\/2018"}